Commentary 17 September 2015

The German NSA Affair and the Need for Reform in Berlin

by Mirko Hohmann              Lawfare Blog

When Chancellor Angela Merkel recently cited the “challenges” concerning the National Security Agency as an area that the German government has “tackled excellently” this term, many observers were surprised – not least because, two years into the “NSA affair,” the German government continues to vocally criticize American surveillance efforts while failing to address the shortcomings of its own intelligence agencies.

On the one hand, judicial control of German surveillance efforts does not exist and parliamentary oversight remains weak. On the other, the relationship between German intelligence agencies and their American counterparts remains asymmetric. Both issues have implications beyond German borders: They not only undermine Germany’s legitimacy as an international advocate for privacy and data protection, but also impede consistent transatlantic intelligence cooperation.

Indicative of such troubles are recent revelations of cooperation between the National Security Agency and the German domestic intelligence service – called Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz, or BfV. In August, the German newspaper Die Zeit disclosed the “terms of reference” of an agreement between BfV and NSA. The BfV had apparently made a questionable bargain: In exchange for access to the NSA’s powerful search-and-analysis software, XKeyscore, BfV agreed to “share all data relevant to NSA's mission” with the American intelligence agency “to the maximum extent possible.”

To read the full piece, please visit the Lawfare Blog.

Essay 27 August 2018

Wider das autoritäre Modell

by Thorsten Benner, Mirko Hohmann
Internationale Politik

Book 16 July 2018

Cybersecurity in Germany

by Isabel Skierka, Martin Schallbruch
Springer

Policy Paper 28 June 2018

How European Internet Foreign Policy Can Compete in a Fragmented World

by Mirko Hohmann, Thorsten Benner
GPPi

Commentary 19 April 2018

Digital Geneva Convention: Microsoft als Normunternehmer

by Thorsten Benner
Microsoft Berlin

Commentary 12 April 2018

Germany’s Half-Baked Approach to Fighting Disinformation

by Alexander Pirang
Council on Foreign Relations